Verdictly
Verdict-Plaintiff
Harris County • 2015

Texas Judge Awards $11,416 in Deceptive Trade Practices Case

One driver sued a collision center after their car was towed and repaired. The driver alleged deceptive practices and unconscionable conduct, claiming they were misled about repairs and payment. The collision center counterclaimed for repair and storage costs. The court found in favor of the driver.

Case Information Updated: October 2025

Back to cases
Other Injury
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

Case Outcome

Outcome
Verdict-Plaintiff
Amount
$11,417
County
Harris County, TX
Resolved
2015

Injury & Accident Details

Injury Type
Other
Accident Type
Other
Case Type
Motor Vehicle Negligence

Case Overview

In May 2014, following a motor vehicle accident involving the plaintiff's 2003 BMW, the defendant, Allied Collision Center Inc., towed the vehicle from the scene. The plaintiff alleged the defendant's wrecker driver required her to sign a blank invoice before towing, purportedly stating the car would go to storage only and she could select a body shop later. Days later, the plaintiff requested to move the vehicle elsewhere, but the defendant stated work had already commenced. The defendant maintained the signed form authorized repairs.

The plaintiff sued the defendant under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, alleging unconscionable conduct and false, misleading, and deceptive acts. She also contended the defendant refused to release her vehicle without full payment of the insurance repair estimate, despite having performed minimal work. The defendant counterclaimed for unjust enrichment and quantum meruit for work performed and storage. The plaintiff denied the counterclaim, arguing the work and most storage were unauthorized.

The plaintiff sought the value of her vehicle, estimated at $7,000 including sentimental value, and multiple damages under the DTPA, asserting the defendant's conduct was knowing and intentional. She also sought car rental expenses, attorney fees, and litigation costs. The defendant disputed these claims, citing the car's market value was under $3,000, its pre-existing collision damage, and salvage title. The defendant also argued a lack of documentation for certain expenses and costs.

Following a bench trial, the court found the defendant engaged in unconscionable conduct and false, misleading, and deceptive acts, deeming these actions knowing and intentional. The court awarded the plaintiff $2,634.23 in actual damages, $5,268.46 in multiple damages, $3,913.93 in attorney fees, and $500 in litigation costs, totaling $11,416.62. The defendant announced plans to appeal the judgment and requested the court strike findings on attorney fees and litigation costs.

VerdictlyTM Score

94
/100
Highly Fair

This outcome aligns very well with similar cases

This score is calculated by analyzing injury type, accident details, geographic location, temporal trends, and comparing against 2,000+ similar cases in our database.

Need results like this for your case?

Share your situation and we'll connect you with experienced motor vehicle accident attorneys who have handled cases like this in Harris County.

Similar cases you may find useful

Handpicked by matching injury type, accident details, and outcome to this case.

$125,000
Verdict-Plaintiff
Other Injury
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A case was filed in Texas by the plaintiffs against an individual defendant and defendant Rockwell Collins, Inc. Few details were available regarding the incident that led to the lawsuit or the specific legal claims asserted. The record indicated the case concluded on June 12, 2015. No further information was provided regarding the arguments of each side, the outcome, or the reasons for the verdict or judgment.

Tarrant County • 2015
View full case
$9,973
Verdict-Plaintiff
Shoulder Injury
Other Accident
Aggravation of Pre-existing Condition

In October 2011, a plaintiff was driving a compact car eastbound on Interstate 10 in Harris County, Texas. While moving to the outside shoulder to yield to an approaching fire truck, the plaintiff's vehicle struck a rectangular hole in the pavement, causing a right front tire blowout. The hole, approximately two feet long and several inches deep, had resulted from the removal of a traffic-counting device and had not been refilled. The plaintiff alleged a shoulder injury. The plaintiff filed a premises liability lawsuit against the Texas Department of Transportation, alleging the hole constituted an unreasonably dangerous "special defect" that the agency knew or should have known about. The court ruled that the hole was a special defect as a matter of law. The defendant denied knowledge of the condition and contended that the plaintiff was negligent for failing to keep a proper lookout. The plaintiff claimed the incident aggravated a pre-existing partial rotator cuff tear, while the defense argued the injury was entirely pre-existing and noted a six-month gap in the plaintiff's treatment history. After a two-day trial, a jury found the Texas Department of Transportation negligent and awarded the plaintiff $9,973. The jury's finding of negligence was based on the determination that the defendant "knew or should have known" of the dangerous condition. The jury did not find the defendant negligent based on "actual knowledge," nor did it find the plaintiff comparatively negligent. The award included damages for past medical costs, past physical impairment, past lost earning capacity, and past physical pain.

Harris County • 2015
View full case
$7,000
Settlement
Other Injury
Other Accident
Economic Injury

A plaintiff filed a negligence lawsuit in Dallas County, Texas, alleging that on April 2, 2012, a defendant negligently operated a vehicle. The plaintiff claimed the defendant failed to yield while making a turn, causing a collision with the plaintiff's car. The plaintiff alleged injuries from the incident. The lawsuit was filed on April 1, 2014, in the District Court, 14th District Court, Dallas County, Texas. The parties later reached a settlement agreement on June 26, 2015. Under the terms, the plaintiff accepted $7,000 in full settlement of all claims. On July 9, 2015, the court entered an agreed order dismissing the case with prejudice based on the parties' joint motion.

Dallas County • 2015
View full case
$500
Verdict-Plaintiff
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

In Tarrant County, a plaintiff filed a lawsuit alleging negligence following a motor vehicle accident. The plaintiff claimed to have sustained bodily injuries, specifically soft tissue damage to the neck and back, as a result of the incident. A jury heard the case and delivered an 11-1 verdict in favor of the plaintiff. The jury found the defendant negligent and awarded damages totaling $2,226. This amount included $500 for past physical pain and mental anguish, and $1,726 for past medical care.

Tarrant County • 2015
View full case
Undisclosed
Settlement
Other Injury
Truck/Commercial
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A negligence case was filed following a motor vehicle incident that involved a commercial vehicle. The plaintiff brought the action against the defendant. A defense expert specializing in areas such as forensic auditing and transportation safety was involved in the proceedings. The parties reached a settlement agreement, concluding the case on June 30, 2015.

Hidalgo County • 2015
View full case