Smith County Jury Awards $352,874 in Left Turn Collision
One driver was traveling south on a highway when another driver made a left turn from a stop sign and collided with them. The injured driver sought damages for aggravation of pre-existing degenerative conditions in their neck and lower back, including claims for medical expenses, pain, and impairment. The defense argued the accident did not worsen the pre-existing conditions or necessitate surgery.
Case Information Updated: October 2025
Case Outcome
- Outcome
- Verdict-Plaintiff
- Amount
- $352,874
- County
- Smith County, TX
- Resolved
- 2023
Injury & Accident Details
- Injury Type
- Cervical Disc Injury
- Accident Type
- T-bone
- Case Type
- back, lower back, neck
Case Overview
On March 7, 2020, a collision occurred on a highway in Smith County when a driver, identified as the defendant, made a left turn from a stop sign. The defendant's vehicle was struck by a vehicle driven by the plaintiff, a 65-year-old salesperson. The impact was severe.
The plaintiff subsequently filed a lawsuit, alleging the accident aggravated preexisting degenerative cervical and lumbar conditions, including bulging discs. The plaintiff sought damages for past and future medical expenses, physical pain, mental anguish, and physical impairment. The plaintiff's counsel argued the defendant had admitted responsibility for the accident in a deposition. Medical treatment included chiropractic care, massage therapy, physical therapy, and lumbar epidural steroid injections. A neurosurgeon recommended cervical and lumbar fusions, estimated at $275,000, with paid medical bills totaling $37,874, which the defense stipulated as reasonable and necessary. The jury also received an "eggshell plaintiff" instruction.
The defense argued that the defendant's view was obstructed by a pickup truck towing a boat on the southbound shoulder at the time of the turn. The defense also presented an orthopedic surgeon who testified that the accident did not exacerbate the plaintiff's preexisting conditions or necessitate surgery. The plaintiff's counsel contended this defense expert's trial testimony contradicted an earlier report that had agreed with the surgical recommendations.
Following a two-day trial and 2.5 hours of deliberation, a Smith County jury found the defendant liable. The jury awarded the plaintiff $352,874. The award included $37,874 for past medical costs, $200,000 for future medical costs, and additional amounts for past and future physical impairment, physical pain, and mental anguish.
VerdictlyTM Score
This outcome significantly deviates from similar cases
This score is calculated by analyzing injury type, accident details, geographic location, temporal trends, and comparing against 2,000+ similar cases in our database.
Deserve a fair outcome for your case?
Share your situation and we'll connect you with experienced motor vehicle accident attorneys who have handled cases like this in Smith County.
Similar cases you may find useful
Handpicked by matching injury type, accident details, and outcome to this case.
On August 14, 2014, a vehicular collision occurred in Houston, Texas, when the defendant's vehicle struck the rear of the plaintiff's vehicle. The plaintiff alleged the defendant, operating a company vehicle within the scope of employment, was traveling at an excessive rate of speed, failed to maintain a proper lookout, and did not keep a safe distance, causing severe injuries to the plaintiff's cervical and lumbar spine. The plaintiff filed a negligence lawsuit, claiming the defendant's actions led to significant neck and back disc injuries. The defendant failed to answer the complaint, resulting in a default judgment entered by the court. The court awarded the plaintiff $364,305 in damages. This included $200,000 for pain and suffering, $14,305 for past medical expenses, and $150,000 for future medical expenses. The judgment was granted due to the defendant's failure to respond to the legal complaint.
A plaintiff filed a vehicular negligence action after his stopped vehicle was struck from the rear by a defendant's vehicle on April 10, 2014, at an intersection in Houston, Texas. The plaintiff alleged the defendant failed to control the vehicle, maintain a proper lookout, and take evasive action. The plaintiff claimed to have sustained an ankle sprain and discogenic injuries to the cervical and lumbar spine as a result of the collision. The defendant denied all allegations of negligence, including that the plaintiff sustained serious or permanent injuries from the accident. A jury ultimately found the defendant negligent. The jury awarded the plaintiff $16,361 for past damages and an additional $10,000 for future damages.
On September 16, 2012, a vehicle collision occurred in Dallas County, Texas. The plaintiff alleged that a defendant driver negligently failed to stop at a red traffic light, causing an intersection accident with the plaintiff's car. The plaintiff claimed to have sustained personal injuries in the crash. On February 5, 2014, the plaintiff filed a negligence lawsuit against the defendant driver and the vehicle owner defendant in District Court in Dallas County. The parties subsequently reached a settlement through mediation on January 22, 2015. A judge then entered an agreed order on February 10, 2015, dismissing the suit with prejudice.
On September 19, 2013, a front-seat passenger in a sedan was injured when the vehicle was rear-ended by a 15-passenger van on Interstate 37 Frontage Road in Corpus Christi, Texas. The plaintiff, a carpenter, subsequently filed a lawsuit against the van driver and the driver's employer, alleging vehicular negligence and claiming the collision aggravated a pre-existing back injury. The plaintiff reported immediate back pain that worsened the following day, leading to an emergency room visit. An orthopedic surgeon later confirmed the collision aggravated a pre-existing degenerative disc disease. The plaintiff, who had a non-debilitating history of back pain, underwent physical therapy, steroid injections, and ultimately a two-level lumbar fusion. Treating physicians testified the collision necessitated surgery and affected his ability to perform manual labor. The plaintiff sought damages for past and future medical costs, lost wages, and pain and mental anguish. While the defendants did not dispute negligence for the collision, they contested causation and the extent of injury. The defense argued the impact was minor, noting the police report indicated no immediate injuries and the van was traveling at low speed. Defense experts opined the plaintiff's back problems were attributable to his pre-existing degenerative condition, not the accident, and that he would sustain no wage loss. Following a five-day trial, the jury found the defendant driver negligent and determined his negligence was a factual cause of the plaintiff's injuries. The jury awarded the plaintiff $563,003 in damages. The court subsequently added $32,257.69 for pre-judgment interest and court costs, resulting in a total judgment of $595,360.46 for the plaintiff.
A case was filed in Texas by the plaintiffs against an individual defendant and defendant Rockwell Collins, Inc. Few details were available regarding the incident that led to the lawsuit or the specific legal claims asserted. The record indicated the case concluded on June 12, 2015. No further information was provided regarding the arguments of each side, the outcome, or the reasons for the verdict or judgment.