Verdictly
Verdict-Plaintiff
Harris County • 2016

Montgomery County Jury Awards $2,925,450 in Truck Negligence Case

A rancher was on his ATV near his property entrance when an 18-wheeler reversed and collided with the ATV, pushing it about 15 feet. The rancher claimed neck injuries. The defense argued the truck did not strike the ATV and that the rancher was distracted. Medical experts disagreed on the cause and severity of the claimed injuries.

Case Information Updated: October 2025

Back to cases
Cervical Disc Injury
Truck/Commercial

Case Outcome

Outcome
Verdict-Plaintiff
Amount
$2,955,000
County
Harris County, TX
Resolved
2016

Injury & Accident Details

Injury Type
Cervical Disc Injury
Accident Type
Truck/Commercial
Case Type
Motor Vehicle Accident

Case Overview

In January 2014, a rancher sustained injuries at the entrance to his Montgomery property, which was adjacent to Jackson Road. The plaintiff had an access agreement with an energy company, Primoris Energy Services, for a pipeline construction project. After hearing that a tractor-trailer had damaged his front gate, the plaintiff arrived on his all-terrain vehicle (ATV) to make a phone call to project management. During this time, an 18-wheeler, operated by a driver for Montgomery Trucking Co. LLC, began to reverse, colliding with the plaintiff's ATV and pushing it approximately 15 feet.

The plaintiff filed a lawsuit against Montgomery Trucking Co. LLC, the driver, and Primoris Energy Services, alleging negligence. The plaintiff claimed the driver operated the vehicle unsafely by failing to see him and that Primoris Energy was negligent in providing inadequate site safety, failing to employ spotters, and ignoring requests for a dedicated construction entrance. An accident reconstruction expert for the plaintiff testified that the driver’s reversal was unsafe, while a treating neurosurgeon linked the plaintiff's cervical disc herniations and subsequent four-level spinal fusion to the collision. A ranch operations expert also testified about the economic impact on the plaintiff's business due to his injuries.

Attorneys for Montgomery Trucking and the driver denied liability, arguing that Primoris Energy's employees failed to ensure safety and that the plaintiff was contributorily negligent for being distracted on his phone and failing to perceive the truck. They also disputed that the truck struck the ATV. Primoris Energy also denied liability and asserted the plaintiff's contributory negligence. Defense experts, including a biomechanical expert, argued the impact speed was insufficient to cause the alleged injuries, while a neurosurgeon contended that the plaintiff's cervical conditions were pre-existing and that the surgery was unnecessary.

After a five-day trial, a jury found in favor of the plaintiff, awarding $2,955,000. The jury determined Montgomery Trucking was 35 percent liable, Primoris Energy Services was 64 percent liable, and the plaintiff was 1 percent liable. The award was reduced to $2,925,450 to reflect the plaintiff's comparative liability. Post-trial motions were anticipated from defense counsel. An indemnity agreement stipulated that Primoris Energy would be indemnified by Montgomery Trucking’s insurers.

VerdictlyTM Score

43
/100
Questionable

This outcome differs from typical similar cases

This score is calculated by analyzing injury type, accident details, geographic location, temporal trends, and comparing against 2,000+ similar cases in our database.

Need better results for your case?

Share your situation and we'll connect you with experienced motor vehicle accident attorneys who have handled cases like this in Harris County.

Similar cases you may find useful

Handpicked by matching injury type, accident details, and outcome to this case.

$364,305
Verdict-Plaintiff
Cervical Disc Injury
Rear-end
Motor Vehicle Negligence

On August 14, 2014, a vehicular collision occurred in Houston, Texas, when the defendant's vehicle struck the rear of the plaintiff's vehicle. The plaintiff alleged the defendant, operating a company vehicle within the scope of employment, was traveling at an excessive rate of speed, failed to maintain a proper lookout, and did not keep a safe distance, causing severe injuries to the plaintiff's cervical and lumbar spine. The plaintiff filed a negligence lawsuit, claiming the defendant's actions led to significant neck and back disc injuries. The defendant failed to answer the complaint, resulting in a default judgment entered by the court. The court awarded the plaintiff $364,305 in damages. This included $200,000 for pain and suffering, $14,305 for past medical expenses, and $150,000 for future medical expenses. The judgment was granted due to the defendant's failure to respond to the legal complaint.

Harris County • 2015
View full case
$23,361
Verdict-Plaintiff
Cervical Disc Injury
Rear-end
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A plaintiff filed a vehicular negligence action after his stopped vehicle was struck from the rear by a defendant's vehicle on April 10, 2014, at an intersection in Houston, Texas. The plaintiff alleged the defendant failed to control the vehicle, maintain a proper lookout, and take evasive action. The plaintiff claimed to have sustained an ankle sprain and discogenic injuries to the cervical and lumbar spine as a result of the collision. The defendant denied all allegations of negligence, including that the plaintiff sustained serious or permanent injuries from the accident. A jury ultimately found the defendant negligent. The jury awarded the plaintiff $16,361 for past damages and an additional $10,000 for future damages.

Harris County • 2015
View full case
$292,000
Verdict-Plaintiff
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Rear-end

On January 4, 2013, a pick-up truck towing a trailer was involved in a rear-end collision with an armored vehicle on a highway. The plaintiff, driving the pick-up, sustained injuries to their back and knee. The armored vehicle was operated by a defendant driver and owned by a defendant employer. The plaintiff filed a petition against the defendants in the District Court for Harris County, Texas, on September 27, 2015. The lawsuit alleged that the defendant driver's negligence caused the accident and the plaintiff's injuries. The defendants countered, claiming the plaintiff was negligent by veering into the armored vehicle's lane of travel. Following a trial, a jury on December 9, 2015, found the defendant driver negligent and determined that the plaintiff was not negligent. A judgment was entered on December 30, 2015, awarding the plaintiff $92,000 for past medical expenses, $40,000 for past lost earnings, and $160,000 for past pain and suffering, totaling $292,000. An appellate court later affirmed the trial court's decision.

Harris County • 2015
View full case
$166,231
Verdict-Plaintiff
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Truck/Commercial

On November 7, 2012, a plaintiff alleged that a defendant operator negligently drove a tractor-trailer, causing it to rear-end the plaintiff's stopped vehicle. The plaintiff claimed he sustained personal injuries as a result of the defendant operator's negligence. In October 2014, the plaintiff, along with his wife and minor child, filed a negligence lawsuit against the defendant operator and his employer in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, Waco. A jury trial followed. In October 2015, the jury returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff, awarding him $146,231.28 for personal injuries. The jury also awarded $20,000 in loss of consortium damages to the plaintiff's wife and minor child, bringing the total award to $166,231.28.

Dallas County • 2015
View full case
$130,842
Verdict-Plaintiff
Shoulder Injury
Rear-end
Motor Vehicle Negligence

On June 6, 2013, a rear-end collision occurred in Houston, TX, involving two vehicles traveling northbound. The plaintiff driver alleged that the defendant driver, operating a vehicle owned by the defendant owner, negligently collided into the rear of the plaintiff's vehicle. As a result, the plaintiff claimed to have suffered neck, back, and shoulder injuries, with the shoulder injuries requiring acromionectomy surgery. The plaintiff filed a lawsuit against the defendants, alleging negligence. The defendants admitted liability for the collision itself but disputed the nature, extent, and causation of the plaintiff's claimed injuries and damages. Specifically, the defense argued that the plaintiff had a pre-existing shoulder injury and that the shoulder issues were not causally related to the crash. The matter proceeded to a bench trial. The court found in favor of the plaintiff and awarded total damages of $130,842. This amount included $103,842 for medical expenses, $2,500 for past impairment, and $20,000 for future medical expenses.

Harris County • 2015
View full case