Verdictly
Settlement
Liberty County • 2016

Liberty County, Texas Negligent Trucking Settles for $450,000

One driver was slowing to make a left turn when a tractor-trailer attempted to pass on the left. The tractor-trailer struck the rear corner of the turning vehicle, causing damage. The investigating officer cited the tractor-trailer driver for unsafe passing. The occupants of the car claimed multiple injuries, including neck and back sprains, disc issues, and concussions. The defense argued the turning driver made a sudden turn without signaling.

Case Information Updated: October 2025

Back to cases
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Truck/Commercial
Motor Vehicle Negligence

Case Outcome

Outcome
Settlement
Amount
$450,000
County
Liberty County, TX
Resolved
2016

Injury & Accident Details

Injury Type
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Accident Type
Truck/Commercial
Case Type
Motor Vehicle Negligence

Case Overview

On April 20, 2015, a two-vehicle collision occurred on State Highway 105 in Liberty County, Texas. As the driver of a Honda Civic slowed to make a left turn, a tractor-trailer operated by an employee of Charity Shoes and Clothing LLC attempted to pass on the left, striking the Civic's rear. The plaintiff driver claimed her turn signal was active, while the defense alleged a sudden, unsignaled turn. Investigators cited the truck driver for an unsafe pass. Both the Civic's driver and passenger sustained injuries, including concussions, spinal disc issues, and various sprains, requiring medical treatment and claiming work limitations.

The plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against the truck driver, alleging negligent passing, failure to yield, and other traffic violations. They also sued Charity Shoes and Clothing LLC, asserting negligent hiring and supervision against the employer, citing the truck driver's alleged prior convictions. The defense denied negligence, maintaining the plaintiff driver was at fault. The defense also disputed the causation of the passenger's injuries due to a treatment gap.

The parties reached a settlement of $450,000 during mediation. The Civic's driver received $375,000, and the passenger received $75,000. This settlement was within the defendants' $1 million insurance policy limit.

VerdictlyTM Score

38
/100
Potentially Unfair

This outcome significantly deviates from similar cases

This score is calculated by analyzing injury type, accident details, geographic location, temporal trends, and comparing against 2,000+ similar cases in our database.

Deserve a fair outcome for your case?

Share your situation and we'll connect you with experienced motor vehicle accident attorneys who have handled cases like this in Liberty County.

Similar cases you may find useful

Handpicked by matching injury type, accident details, and outcome to this case.

$7,100
Settlement
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Rear-end
Economic Injury

On July 9, 2013, a vehicle operated by the defendant allegedly rear-ended a car driven by the plaintiff. The plaintiff claimed the defendant negligently failed to yield and ran a red light, sustaining personal injuries in the incident. On April 8, 2014, the plaintiff filed a negligence petition for damages against the defendant in the District Court, 44th District Court, Dallas County, Texas. On February 10, 2015, the parties informed the court they had reached a settlement. The agreement provided that the plaintiff would accept $7,100 to resolve all claims. An agreed order of dismissal with prejudice was entered on February 20, 2015.

Dallas County • 2015
View full case
$563,003
Verdict-Plaintiff
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Rear-end
Motor Vehicle Negligence

On September 19, 2013, a front-seat passenger in a sedan was injured when the vehicle was rear-ended by a 15-passenger van on Interstate 37 Frontage Road in Corpus Christi, Texas. The plaintiff, a carpenter, subsequently filed a lawsuit against the van driver and the driver's employer, alleging vehicular negligence and claiming the collision aggravated a pre-existing back injury. The plaintiff reported immediate back pain that worsened the following day, leading to an emergency room visit. An orthopedic surgeon later confirmed the collision aggravated a pre-existing degenerative disc disease. The plaintiff, who had a non-debilitating history of back pain, underwent physical therapy, steroid injections, and ultimately a two-level lumbar fusion. Treating physicians testified the collision necessitated surgery and affected his ability to perform manual labor. The plaintiff sought damages for past and future medical costs, lost wages, and pain and mental anguish. While the defendants did not dispute negligence for the collision, they contested causation and the extent of injury. The defense argued the impact was minor, noting the police report indicated no immediate injuries and the van was traveling at low speed. Defense experts opined the plaintiff's back problems were attributable to his pre-existing degenerative condition, not the accident, and that he would sustain no wage loss. Following a five-day trial, the jury found the defendant driver negligent and determined his negligence was a factual cause of the plaintiff's injuries. The jury awarded the plaintiff $563,003 in damages. The court subsequently added $32,257.69 for pre-judgment interest and court costs, resulting in a total judgment of $595,360.46 for the plaintiff.

Nueces County • 2015
View full case
$500
Verdict-Plaintiff
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Other Accident
Motor Vehicle Negligence

In Tarrant County, a plaintiff filed a lawsuit alleging negligence following a motor vehicle accident. The plaintiff claimed to have sustained bodily injuries, specifically soft tissue damage to the neck and back, as a result of the incident. A jury heard the case and delivered an 11-1 verdict in favor of the plaintiff. The jury found the defendant negligent and awarded damages totaling $2,226. This amount included $500 for past physical pain and mental anguish, and $1,726 for past medical care.

Tarrant County • 2015
View full case
Undisclosed
Settlement
Other Injury
Truck/Commercial
Motor Vehicle Negligence

A negligence case was filed following a motor vehicle incident that involved a commercial vehicle. The plaintiff brought the action against the defendant. A defense expert specializing in areas such as forensic auditing and transportation safety was involved in the proceedings. The parties reached a settlement agreement, concluding the case on June 30, 2015.

Hidalgo County • 2015
View full case
$30,003
Verdict-Plaintiff
Back Strain / Soft Tissue
Rear-end
Motor Vehicle Negligence

On March 13, 2012, a plaintiff was injured in a multi-vehicle collision while driving in slow traffic near Highway 59 in Houston, Texas. The defendant driver reportedly swerved into the plaintiff's lane, striking a vehicle behind the plaintiff, which then collided with the rear of the plaintiff's slowing car. The plaintiff subsequently filed a vehicular negligence action. The plaintiff alleged the defendant was negligent in failing to maintain a proper lookout, operating a vehicle unsafely, and failing to apply brakes in a timely manner, which led to injuries including to the chest, neck, back, and a partial to full thickness tear of the right rotator cuff. The defendant denied all allegations of negligence and injury. Following the proceedings, the court found the defendant negligent and that this negligence caused harm to the plaintiff. The plaintiff was awarded $10,000 for past pain and suffering, $10,000 for past disfigurement, and $10,003 for past medical expenses, totaling $30,003.

Harris County • 2015
View full case